The Trouble With Textbooks...
I think I was in fifth grade when I began to suspect that textbooks weren't entirely on the level. The first tip-off came from the word problems in math class. They typically began with scenarios that, even to a 10-year-old, seemed a little unlikely: "Julio's mom is a welder. His father is a pediatric nurse. If his mom welds for 9 hours a day, then..."
Hard-edged propaganda now suffuses America's history textbooks. A thorough cover-to-cover reading of almost any high school history text leaves you with the impression that United States is at best embarrassing, and at worst a menace to world peace.
I think I was in fifth grade when I began to suspect that textbooks weren't entirely on the level. The first tip-off came from the word problems in math class. They typically began with scenarios that, even to a 10-year-old, seemed a little unlikely: "Julio's mom is a welder. His father is a pediatric nurse. If his mom welds for 9 hours a day, then..."
Or: "If Maria wins her first three prizefights by knockout, and her next three by TKO, how long before she can leave her job as a lumberjack and fight full time?"
The characters in my textbooks didn't sound like anyone I had ever met. Years later I realized, that was exactly the point. The educators who wrote them weren't interested in describing the world as it was, or had been, but rather as they wanted it to be. They were ideologues, and my math and history books were their pamphlets, disguised as academic texts.
Thirty years later, few textbooks bother with the disguise. Entire chunks of the English language have been banned from the classroom, liquidated in a P.C. purge. First to go were words containing the dreaded term "man," the three letters most offensive to professional feminists. Mailman, chairman, snowman, fisherman, manhole cover--every one now extinct, disdained relics of a bygone age.
Yet even flat ignorance is better (and certainly more amusing) than the hard-edged propaganda that now suffuses history textbooks. A thorough cover-to-cover reading of almost any high school history text leaves you with the impression that the United States is at best embarrassing, and at worst a menace to world peace. The internment of Japanese-Americans during World War Two gets almost us much emphasis as the American liberation of Europe.
Don't take my word for it. Make a pledge to yourself to look through your children's textbooks this year. Take a look at what's there, but also at what's missing. If you find bias or distortions, don't be silent. Raise holy hell. Someday your kids will thank you for it.

Comments
A Student - Central CA - 06/15/2010
First, I'm surprised a textbook publisher would allow this on their site! From their website though, it sounds like they are the "anti-BIG guys" too.
It is interesting that the finger is rarely pointed at the textbook publisher as the source of the "problem". Teachers get blamed first, students, parents, administration, budget...everything except the curriculum. I have spent so much time as a teacher finding or creating supplements to our text that sometimes, I feel like a publisher!
D - CA - 03/15/2010
Leave a comment
Back to Previous Page